This week I was able to finally, after missing a week because of Hurricane Sandy, work with the 2nd grade students. The idea started during the 2nd grade States of Matter unit. Students kept coming up with some amazing questions. Ms. DeBonis and her students teacher, Ms. Olyha, had the students record their questions about solids (we allowed some liquid questions in there as well). After reading through the questions we were able to group them into a few categories. The same four categories tended to pop up in one way or another.
1) Can solids float?
2) Can solids melt?
3) Can you change the shape of a solid?
4) Can you turn something that is not a solid (i.e. liquid) into a solid?
During our planning meeting we designed four stations based on these questions. The stations are listed below. Students then used their Science Notebooks and the
graphic organizer to make observations and illustrate those observations. The students were thoroughly engaged and generated several deeper questions during the stations.
Station 1 - Can solids float?
We filled a container with water and had the students make predictions on if they thought our objects would sink or float. The objects we used were a pumpkin and a sponge (just a regular dish washing sponge). The students were amazed when they found out both floated, especially the pumpkin. What amazed me was how each group at one point place the pumpkin on top of the sponge to make it sink.
Station 2 - Can solids melt?
For this station we filled a glass beaker (about 1/2 way) with hot water. The students then placed one ice cube into a smaller beaker and gently dropped that into the beaker with hot water. We made predictions about what we thought would happen. Once we removed the smaller beaker and saw how quickly it melted I allowed the students to touch the bottom and side of the smaller beaker. This allowed for an additional observation - the bottom of the beaker was ice cold and the sides were warm and had condensation on them. A few students wondered what would happen if we just dropped the ice cube in the water. She answered her own question with quite an explanation about how the glass of the small beaker prevents the ice from melting quickly.
Station 3 - Can you change the shape of a solid?
Students used modeling clay to make a variety of shapes.
Station 4 - Can you turn something that is not a solid into a solid?
This was probably the students favorite station. At this station we filled an ice tray with water, which the students observed throughout the day, to notice the different changes in the liquid. Once they filled the ice tray, they were then allowed to make
ice cream in a bag. A huge hit!